Unlike Xavier, Tyler is still involved in the show. However, his chances with Wednesday are slimmer than slim, because her actions in Season 1 led to him being imprisoned in Willow Hill Psychiatric Hospital. She visits him there in Season 2, episode 2, where he tries to make a romantic appeal to her dark side.

After leaving Silver Falls, Nikki Rodriguez's Jackie comes back only to have to find her place again and sort out where her heart lies.